Lake Geneva Pie Co

Located in the heart of Lake Geneva at 150 E Geneva Square, Lake Geneva Pie Co is a delightful haven for pie lovers and dessert aficionados alike. This charming eatery effortlessly blends the cozy ambiance of a classic bakery with the inviting warmth of a café, creating a perfect spot to indulge in artisanal sweets and savory bites.

Lake Geneva Pie Co specializes in an array of mouthwatering pies and baked goods that are both comforting and sophisticated. Whether you're craving a flaky, savory quiche or the nostalgic burst of sweet-and-tart fruit pies, their menu delivers with exquisite craftsmanship. Standouts like the Strawberry Rhubarb Pie, bursting with juicy, tangy fruit wrapped in golden, buttery crust, and the Blackberry Raspberry Pie, rich with luscious berry flavors, exemplify their mastery. For those seeking classic Americana desserts, the Blueberry Pie and Lemon Meringue Pie offer a perfect balance of freshness and sweetness, while the Apple Crisp and Naturally Apple Pie speak to timeless home-baked goodness.

The delightful range extends beyond pies to include coffee cake and the innovative You Take N’ Bake Fruit Pies, perfect for bringing a taste of Lake Geneva home or gifting to loved ones. Guests rave about the peanut butter cookies, noted for their irresistibly soft texture and rich flavor—it's easy to see why they inspire many to return despite long distances.

Beyond the food, the atmosphere at Lake Geneva Pie Co is both quaint and welcoming, with touches like tic-tac-toe games at the tables adding a playful charm to your visit. The staff are consistently commended for their warm hospitality and knowledgeable service, making each visit feel personal and special.

The high praise from regulars and first-time visitors alike brings the experience vividly to life. One frequent traveler sums it up perfectly: "This one is a gem... If you have a sweet tooth as I do, I would definitely recommend to try this place." Another customer reflects on the exceptional crust and friendly service, emotions echoed by many who have found their new pie destination here.

For anyone visiting Lake Geneva or locals seeking a special treat, Lake Geneva Pie Co offers a genuine slice of happiness with every bite—a harmonious blend of traditional favorites and creative flair that satisfies deep cravings and lifts the spirit.